What are the advantages and disadvantages of Epoxy, Polyurethane, and Silicone Adhesives?

by on November 27, 2019

Epoxy

 

Epoxy, polyurethane, and silicone adhesives are the three most popular chemistries packaged at Appli-Tec. The choice of which chemistry to use is based on the application requirements. The following examines the advantages and/or disadvantages each type exhibits.

Epoxies

Epoxies are known for their high strength bonds to a variety of substrates, as well as chemical and moisture resistance and high modulus. Epoxy adhesives are generally hard and brittle, but can be modified to exhibit flexibility and toughness.

They are also easily modified for thermal and/or electrical conductivity, reduced shrinkage, light stability, lower thermal expansion, and a range of glass transition temperatures (Tg). They can be formulated to be both one-part heat cure systems and two-part room temperature cure systems.

Polyurethanes

Polyurethanes are usually softer than epoxies with lower Tg, modulus, and strength, but with higher elongation. They can be environmentally resistant with tough, flexible bonds. They exhibit lower exotherm on cure than epoxy, resulting in reduced shrinkage.

Good for low operating temperatures, they tend to suffer property degradation above 125°C. Like epoxies, they also can be modified for thermal and electrical conductivity and lower thermal expansion. A range of properties can be achieved as well as flexible cure times.

One-part polyurethanes are heat or moisture cured. Two-part polyurethanes are available in room temperature, heat, and moisture cure options.

Silicones

Silicones are resistant to high temperatures and chemicals. They typically have lower Tg and modulus than epoxies and lower adhesion strength than both epoxy and polyurethane adhesives, often requiring primers.

Due to their excellent safety profile, silicone adhesives and sealants are often used in medical applications. Both two-part and one-part systems are available with a range of cure mechanisms.

The chart below illustrates some of the advantages and disadvantages of the three adhesive chemistries most often made and packaged by Appli-Tec.

Epoxy

Pros:

  • Excellent bond strength
  • Excellent adhesion to a variety of substrates
  • Can be formulated to have a wide range of properties
  • Good chemical and moisture resistance

Cons:

  • Can be brittle without modification
  • Thermal stability limited to ~ 185-200°C
  • Ingredients can be hazardous to handle

Polyurethane

Pros:

  • Lower modulus than epoxies
  • Good adhesion
  • Tough
  • Moisture barrier
  • Good low temperature performance

Cons:

  • Lower bond strength than epoxies
  • Lower operating temperature range (max 125C)
  • Moisture sensitive ingredients prior to curing
  • Ingredients can be hazardous to handle
  • Cure conditions and moisture exposure can affect end properties.

RTV Silicone

Pros:

  • Operating temperature -65C to 315C
  • Low reaction exotherm
  • Low toxicity
  • Low cure shrinkage
  • Good electrical properties
  • Excellent chemical and environmental resistance

Cons:

  • Lower adhesive strength than epoxy and polyurethanes-often requires a primer step
  • Easily contaminated, causing cure issues
  • If poorly formulated, can outgas, causing contamination of adjacent components

Cryo-PacRegardless of the chemistry your application requires, Appli-Tec can utilize our precision mix and freeze process to turn your two-part adhesive kits into one-part syringes for ease of use.

Contact us to find out more about our capabilities and how we can help you.

Alisha Adams

Alisha Adams is the Research and Development Lead for Appli-Tec. Her expertise includes formulating epoxy and acrylate adhesives for the electronics market.

See more articles by Alisha »

How to get started

Whether you need a quote or you have questions about material availability, we can help.

Appli-Tec Customer Support

Super smart adhesive info for engineers by engineers.

Plus a little humor too. Delivered to your inbox once a month.